Are you an accident victim? LET ME HELP YOU SEEK JUSTICE.
Woman slips and falls on outdoor staircase

Premises Liability and Foreseeable Harm 

The FostelLaw Firm May 14, 2024

Premises liability is a critical legal concept designed to hold property owners accountable for maintaining safe conditions for visitors and patrons.  

A crucial aspect of this legal framework revolves around "foreseeable harm," which refers to whether a reasonably prudent person would anticipate the potential for danger based on the circumstances.  

The Fundamentals of Premises Liability

Property owners are legally required to take reasonable measures to ensure their premises are safe for those who enter.  

This responsibility applies to a wide range of visitors, including customers, tenants, and in some cases, even trespassers. It spans across various property types, from residential buildings to commercial establishments and public spaces. 

A key component in pursuing a premises liability lawsuit is proving negligence on the part of the property owner. Negligence means the property owner did not fulfill their duty of care, resulting in someone else's harm. 

To prove negligence in a premises liability case, the plaintiff must establish four key elements: 

  1. Duty of Care: The plaintiff must demonstrate that the property owner had a legal obligation to ensure the safety of the premises for visitors. 

  1. Breach of Duty: It must be shown that the property owner failed to fulfill this duty of care. This could be through inaction, such as neglecting necessary repairs, or through action that directly created a hazardous situation.  

  1. Causation: The plaintiff needs to illustrate a direct link between the property owner's breach of duty and the injury sustained. If the harm was foreseeable, meaning a reasonable person could predict that the failure to act or incorrect action by the property owner could lead to injury, then it strengthens the case for causation.

    Essentially, if the property owner could foresee the potential harm but failed to take preventive measures, they can be held liable for the resulting injuries. 

  1. Damages: Finally, the plaintiff must provide evidence of the harm suffered. This can include physical injuries, medical expenses, lost wages, and sometimes, emotional distress. 

Victims of injuries on someone else's property have the right to seek compensation through a personal injury claim. This process involves demonstrating the property owner's negligence and establishing a link between this negligence and the injury. 

Understanding Foreseeable Harm

Foreseeability is determined by whether a person of ordinary intelligence could predict a potential danger in a given situation. This concept plays a significant role in determining if a property owner could reasonably have anticipated a risk and taken steps to mitigate it. 

The notion of foreseeability is subjective and can be influenced by several factors, including prior incidents on the property, the type and location of a hazard, and the nature of the enterprise operated there. 

There are exceptional cases where harm that wasn't foreseen still results in liability if the property owner failed to properly address an unanticipated risk. 

Legal practitioners must sift through the details of each individual case to determine whether a property owner could have reasonably anticipated the risks present. This evaluation often hinges on a property owner’s knowledge of previous similar incidents, the obviousness of a hazard, and general safety standards within an industry. 


For instance, consider a scenario involving a property owner who has neglected to address the presence of asbestos in an older building. If tenants or workers become ill due to long-term asbestos exposure, this situation could be grounds for a premises liability case.

Here, the duty of care would include the property owner's responsibility to either remove the hazardous material or to adequately warn those occupying the building about its presence.  

However, if the owner ignored the known risks associated with asbestos—a well-documented hazard—the failure to act could be seen as a clear breach of duty.  

Given the extensive public knowledge regarding the dangers of asbestos, causing respiratory issues and cancers, it's reasonable to argue that the harm was foreseeable.

Consequently, if individuals suffer health complications directly linked to asbestos exposure within the property, the owner could be held liable for the damages, including medical expenses, pain, suffering, and loss of income, under the premises liability law. 

Conversely, if an injury occurs under highly unusual circumstances that a property owner could not have anticipated, establishing foreseeability—and by extension, liability—becomes more challenging.

For example, if a tree on a property spontaneously falls without previous signs of instability or disease, damaging visitor's property or causing injury, the owner might not be held liable if there were truly no signs of potential danger. 

Ultimately, the concept of foreseeable harm is integral to premises liability law, serving as a benchmark for determining when a property owner’s negligence has led to someone else’s injury. 

Constructive Notice in Relation to Foreseeable Harm

The concept of constructive notice holds a property owner accountable for being aware of hazardous conditions on their property, even if they weren't explicitly informed of them. It's predicated on the assumption that, through reasonable diligence, the owner should have known about the danger. 

Proving constructive notice requires evidence that a hazard was present long enough or was so typical that the owner should have discovered it through due care. 

One example could involve a tenant being injured due to a broken stair railing in an apartment building. If previous complaints about the railing had been ignored by the landlord, it can be argued that the landlord had constructive notice of the hazard. The landlord's failure to repair the broken railing, leading to an injury, could then be considered a breach of their duty of care under premises liability law. 

Actions to Take Following an Incident

If you've been injured on someone else's property, it's important to take certain steps immediately following the incident to protect your rights and strengthen any potential legal claim.  

First and foremost, seek medical attention for your injuries, even if they appear minor at first glance. Documenting your injuries through medical records can be a key component in proving the extent and nature of your injuries later on.  

Next, if possible, take photographs of the area where the accident occurred, capturing any hazards or conditions that contributed to your injury. These images can serve as crucial evidence when establishing the property owner's negligence.

If there were any witnesses to your accident, collect their names and contact information as their testimonies could support your claim. Report the incident to the property owner or manager, ensuring that a formal report is filed. Request a copy of this report for your records.  

Then, get in touch with a personal injury attorney who is experienced in premises liability law cases. They can help assess the strength of your claim, help you gather evidence, and negotiate on your behalf for fair compensation. 

The Role of Personal Injury Lawyers

A skilled personal injury attorney brings invaluable expertise to the table, ensuring all legal procedures and negotiations are handled properly, thereby allowing the injured party to concentrate on recovery. 

These lawyers often collaborate with investigators to compile evidence, including video surveillance, maintenance records, and witness testimonies. 

Experienced attorneys adeptly assess the full scope of damages, such as medical expenses, lost income, and non-economic losses like pain and suffering. They work diligently to secure a comprehensive settlement. 

When a settlement cannot be agreed upon, personal injury lawyers are prepared to present the case in court, advocating on their client’s behalf to ensure justice is served. 

Contact an Attorney Today

The concept of foreseeable harm is integral to fostering public safety and holding property owners accountable for their premises. Through an understanding of this principle and prompt action after an injury, individuals can safeguard their rights and seek appropriate compensation.

If you or someone you know is injured on someone else's property, I can help you explore legal avenues. I'm proud to represent clients throughout Texas, the Southeast New Mexico area, and the rest of the country.

Contact The Fostel Law Firm, located in Houston, Texas, today to schedule a free one-on-one consultation. I will offer you the experienced legal guidance you need and help you fight for justice.